Thread automatically updated every 5 second(s). Automatic thread refreshing has been stopped because you appear to be idle. Un-Idle
-
Reload
1Likes -
1 Post By Kira
-
-
-
-
-
-
It was a gift and as such she has no right to ask for it back. You keep hold of it honey x
Cheryl x x x Lost over 8 stones on Lipotrim/Cambridge 
Back to a VLCD to shift a few pounds gained after quitting the ciggies on 31/12/09!
Week One: -8.5lbs
Week Two: -3lbs
Week Three: -2.5lbs
Week Four: -2.5lbs
Week Five: -1.5lbs
Week Six: -2lbs
Week Seven: STS (only to be expected really)
Off plan now until back from holidays x x
-
To be honest if a friend or relative gave me a gift and then asked for it back I'd be inclined to throw it right back at them! I'd make a point of commenting that I'd never accept another gift from them for fear or them wantig it back!! I other words I'd make her feel very small!
Alternatively, something slighlty less honest would be to say you gave a whole load of stuff away following a clear out and the bag went with it? You could still get a dig in about it being a gift and had not expected her to ask for it back in any event? I'm assuming it was a real Louis Vuitton and not a fake one? I have to say I'd never give any of my designer bags away even to my most favourite people!! Hence, I am questioning the authenticity of the bag.
Ekks! Hope that helps ??!!
Kira

-
-
-
-
-
-
Hmmm....sounds like she's regretting her decision! It must be very tempting to say 'tough!' - a gift is a gift after all and legally you are the owner of the bag now.
However...is it worth falling out with her over the bag? I know you are definitely in the right but this is the sort of thing which can end in a massive family feud (I know, I've been there!) and you might decide its best to be the bigger person and hand over the bag - although you can subtly remind her that she owes you a Cath Kidston every time you see her!
Totally your decision and am sure you will make the right one for you. Sounds like you have a very supportive immediate family which is wonderful
xxx

Weeks 1-4
-15lbs 
Weeks 5-8
-5.5lbs (holiday) 
Weeks 9-14 -
6lbs 
Week 15
-3.5lbs 
Week 16
-1lb 
-
She doesn't have any money to replace it, yet she has money to get the zipper fixed? I can't imagine repairing a luxury item such as this would come cheap, especially if she is getting repaired through LV? Then again I guess she could have the repair done cheaper elsewhere.
I'm still of the view to tell her to stuff it and have the stuffing bag back! Oh! With a bit of leaked foundation and mascara etc having "soiled" the bag as you were using as a make up as per her suggestion when she gave it to you as a gift!! That way, you maintain your integrity!!
Kira

-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.