Hi all
I'm looking at starting but not sure wether to go for 4 packs or 3 and a meal. What do you all do?
Thanks
I have this question too! Can't decide whether I sjould just taboo food for a few months and go with 4...agh decisions!
There is no "TRY". There is only "DO" or "NOT DO"
100% for 12 weeks straight - CHALLENGE END DATE: 9/8/13
Week 1: 7 pounds lost / 36 to go
Week 2: 4 pounds lost / 32 to go
Hi, I generally do four packs a day with some of the allowed veg at tea time so it still feels like a 'proper' meal. On a Sunday though, I tend to change it to three and have a Sunday lunch of meat and veg with the rest of the family. I needed a break from food and tend to find when I'm on any other diet I pretty much obsess with what I can eat next! S&S do suggest you take a multi vitamin on days when you do three packs and a meal just to make sure you're getting everything you need. Hope that helps x

I started with 4 packs, now I do 3 packs and a meal, you can see in my signature where I have introduced food because the losses have dropped right down! Lol :/
2013 Slim & Save Diary - 2012 Exante Diary
02/01/13: 241.8lbs
09/01/13: -11.6lbs (230.2lbs)
16/01/13: -4.6lbs (225.6lbs)
23/01/13: -1lbs (224.6lbs)
30/01/13: -3lbs (221.6lbs)
06/02/13: -2.2lbs (219.4lbs)
13/02/13: -0.2lbs (219.2lbs)
20/02/13: -4.4lbs (214.8lbs)
27/02/13: -1.2lbs (213.6lbs)
06/03/13: -1.2lbs (212.4lbs)
13/03/13: -
20/03/13: -
27/03/13: -0.3lbs (212.1lbs)
03/04/13: -1.0lbs (211.1lbs)
10/04/13: -1.5lbs (209.6lbs)
17/04/13:
24/04/13:
01/05/13:

My losses have stayed pretty steady, I've done 3 packs and a meal from the start pretty much. Personally, I decided that I'd rather have the meal, even if I do lose a tiny bit less each week because it's retraining the way I look at food. I don't want to finish this diet and be afraid of food and letting a single bite of anything cross my lips. My attitude towards food before obviously wasn't healthy but then neither is that. I love having that meal, it makes me feel more normal! It certainly makes this diet far more bearable and even enjoyable for me.
New Year... New Start - onwards and downwards (My Diary)
For anyone that might want to sponsor me on the 12 mile sponsored Walk for Kids here's my sponsorship page
Motivation is what gets you started. Habit is what keeps you going.
Obstacles are things a person sees when he takes his eyes off of the goal.
We would accomplish more things if we did not think of them as impossible.
Lost just under 3 stone on various diets in 2011-2012.
Restarting Slim and Save Jan 2013 to lose the rest!
I'm new too, I chose 4 because I want to eliminate real food entirely.![]()
I chose to do 4 packs a day, no meal, no vegetables but I do have the milk allowance for tea/coffee. Have been on this nearly 4 months now and I am thinking of going down to 3 packs and a meal once I hit my goal. Then reducing the packs as the weeks go on, is scary now that the end is in sight.
GOAL 1 - to no longer be in the obese category DONE 3/11/12
GOAL 2 - to be in the 13 stone something category DONE 10/11/12
GOAL 3 - to be in the 12 stone something category by Christmas DONE 8/12/12
GOAL 4 - to have a 2.7 stone loss by Christmas DONE 15/12/12
GOAL 5 - to be in the 11 stone something category DONE 13/01/13
GOAL 6 - to be a healthy BMI so 11st 9lb DONE 19/01/13
GOAL 7 - to continue on with the plan and get to be 10st 13.5lbs, because I have always wanted to be 10 stone something! The least I have weighed as an adult is 11st3lbs and at the time I thought I was huge but when I see those clothes/photos now I realise I wasn't...but 11st something sounds so much worse than 10st something to me.DONE 16/02/12
Week 1 = - 5.5lb (Dukan)
Week 2 = - 4.5lb (4 packs)
Week 3 = - 5.0lb (4)
Week 4 = - 4.0lb (4)
Week 5 = - 2.0lb (4)
Week 6 = - 3.0lb (4)
Week 7 = - 3.0lb (4)
Week 8 = - 3.5lb (4)
Week 9 = - 3.0lb (4)
Week 10 = - 2.0lb (4)
Week 11= - 4.5lb (4)
Week 12= - 3.5lb (4)
Week 13 = -1.5lb (4)
Week 14 = -3.0lb (4)
Week 15 = -4.5lb (4)
Week 16 = -2.0lb (4)
Week 17 = -0.5lb (4)
Week 18 = -5.0lb (4)
Week 19 = -3.5lb (3 packs/1meal)BELOW GOAL
I'm on three packs and a meal
I feel stuffed every night after tea now
It's teaching me good habits .
I had a good first loss, second appeared as nothing
But lost a lot in inches so it is working great
I suggest the three a day ... If you have a really bad relationship with food, worth doing the three to wean yourself off for the first week then switch to four maybe?
Think maybe if I was willing to spend more though I would of gone on the four a day too..
get a sample pack and make sure you like everything enough to do the four a day ones too haha you could end up not really liking them so you have a meal to look forward to in the evening haha
xoxo
Sent from my iPod touch using MiniMins
(21/1/13)Starting weight 20st1lbs
(2/4/13)Restart weight 18st 4lb
![]()