- Rep Power
Diet: Slimming world extra easy
Start Date: 30th July
Start Weight: 19st1lb
Current Weight: 16st4lb
Goal Weight: 15st0lb
Goal Date: ASAP
Start BMI: 45.8
Current BMI: 39.1
Goal BMI: 36
Total Weight Loss: 2st11lb
Weight to Lose: 1st4lb
% Lost 14.61%
Aw sad I missed this but sounds like a complete waste of time. Yea it would be nice if we could all lose weight alone. I don't go to meetings but I do subscribe to the magazine. It's just whatever works for ppl. 5 pound a week is not a waste of money if it inspires you to continue or picks you up when you are down. Certainly better for you than gastric surgery
2013 challenge - lose 2-3 stone and feel amazing!
I spotted this programme last night and asked my bf to tape it so haven't watched it properly yet. But the clip I saw was the reporter (I assume) trying to say that the classes were a rip off.
I don't go to class as I don't feel I would benefit from it and I haven't the money to pay each week - that's my personal choice. But who is she to say that they are a waste of time.
A lot of people get a lot out of classes as they can talk to other members about why their losses are small, swap recipe ideas and help each other plan for events. It's not only the counsellor that provides support so for people who say counsellors don't care if people lose or gain.....who gives a damn?! Because people wouldn't give up their time and money each week if they weren't getting something out of it!!! And for every 'bad' class there is a good one so if people aren't getting help then they should swap groups.
SW is a support group and I for one have never seen any SW branded food during my supermarket shop!!! There is no need for branded diet meals when there is so much free food choice. But if some people find it easier to use pre packed meals, I don't see the problem. It's surely better than eating a Big Mac?!
Can't wait to watch it now lol
I recorded this and will find time tomorrow to watch it. I don't go to SW class but I do pay for their online membership and have recently subscribed to the magazine, I will continue to pay for the membership of both even when I have reached target as nothing tastes as good as being slimmer feels :-D
I've known people who have done both WW and SW, of the people who have done WW, not one of them managed to keep the weight off, whereas the people that have done SW, only a few of them put back on - most of them have kept it off. That's inspiration enough to stick with and support SW :-D
- Rep Power
Diet: Calorie counting
Start Date: 15/1/2013
Start Weight: 18st8lb
Current Weight: 17st11lb
Goal Weight: 10st7lb
Goal Date: When it happens
Start BMI: 43.3
Current BMI: 41.4
Goal BMI: 24.5
Total Weight Loss: 0st11lb
Weight to Lose: 7st4lb
% Lost 4.23%
Gonna look on 4oD for this sounds interesting
I watched this yesterday with my boyfriend and I actually don't think I have anything to add, we said everything that you've just said Gazer.
I actually laughed when they compared the ice-creams, how can you compare plain vanilla ice-cream with a flavoured ice-cream and expect them to have the same amount of ingredients in them. Also of course other things are added to low fat foods.
To be fair I'm not surprised though, dispatches is an awful program.
Under 9 stone by the Wedding
Start - 24th Feb - 10 stone 2
3rd March - 10 stone! (2lb down)
I too attend class and for them to say it is a waste of money isn't a true representation of everyone. I think yes some people can go it alone, I myself am not one of those people. I first joined over a year ago and lost almost 2 stone. I then believed I could go it alone at this point I left however without the regular weigh in and support I gained all but 8lbs in 3 months. I need the help and support of the group to keep me on track. So I dont see my 4.95 as a waste of money. It works for me.
Originally Posted by AnnaFaraday
Update to this post - I now have the figures.
Up to 25 members attending, the consultant takes away 25% of the takings
25-50 members attending, the consultant takes away 40% of the takings
50-70 members attending, the consultant takes away 45% of the takings
Over 70 members attending, the consultant takes away 50% of the takings (and that is the top rate)
And out of that the consultant has to pay any expenses, such as petrol, and of course the rent for the venue.
The consultant gets 10p for every pack of hifi bars sold, and 30p for every magazine sold.
class is a waste of money if you weigh and go. the support i get at image therapy is fab so many hints and tips and we have a good laugh too if your only gonna use the scales you may as well just buy a set from argos
I do think that I would still rather weigh & go than buy my own scales though. 1, cos if I had them in the house then I'd be tempted to jump on them every day. 2, cos I need the structure of a weekly weigh in that I am forced to go to.
Originally Posted by cat yoyo greaves
So, for me it's not a waste, but I can see how it would be for others. I just wish these stupid tv shows wouldn't generalise
yes i think this is the problem. It is horses for courses and what works for you might not work for me!
Exactly. They are the same with giving up smoking etc. I gave up with an inhalator & patches. Other people go completely cold turkey. Surely as long as we all get to where we want to be it doesn't matter how we do it (as long as its legal & doesn't hurt anyone obviously )
Originally Posted by sparty
And like all sales based businesses there are other bonuses as well. Weight loss, number of people who stay for body image, number of target members who still come to class etc.
Originally Posted by AnnaFaraday
I watched the first 10 mins or so and was so infuriated by the way it was demonising slimming clubs in general I had to change the channel. I think KingLeds is spot on that people need to decide who the real enemy is - which the companies peddling crap and the advertisers endorsing it IMO, rather than fat people / slimming clubs.
I was surprised at the small portions of ww crisps compared to Walkers, as we all know you get bog all in a bag of walkers anyway Generally I thought they were not great value, but then Poundland here has an aisle of WW stuff, so clearly it's possible to get branded things cheaper. The ease of the obvious branded packaging helps some members I'm sure, and I think if people choose to spend their money that way fair play to them. Yes people *should* pay more attention and know how to work out what's the best value for money / points / syns whatever, but not everyone will / can. C'est la vie
This is all very true but most consultants don't break even for 6 months at least! The license to run a group is £2000 on its own. If you get 50
Originally Posted by gazter
Paying members then you'd get £250 turnover, of which you give at least 55% to SW. Pay for room hire (where I live that's about £80 for 3 hours) plus all the other stuff. You don't actually lake much money without those incentives & bonuses as well.
Personally I have no clue how anyone does it!
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.