I agree - the best plan is the one that is right for you and fits with your lifestyle. but I'm curious why you think SW is too restrictive but I find it to be the absolute opposite. You can eat 'normal' foods with a minimal of weighing and measuring, eat as much as you need to satisfy your hungry, it's family friendly so everyone can eat the same, you still get to eat treats and you can still enjoy takeaways and meals out without ruining your weight loss.