compared to the restrictions of ww, sw does feel like a lot i know. I would give sw a fair good chance, eat what you fancy and how much you fancy (of the right things of course) and give it at least a month, to see how you get on.
whenever you change your eating patterns, there can be a period of adjustment, some people lose a lot more than normal, and some less, but over a month - it balances out.
if you see a dietician, they will promote a very similar eating plan to what you are advised with sw, and ww.
I have seen 3 dieticians over the years, and have lost more weight on sw than with any of them.
here are a few of the things I have had said to me from a dietician (aside from eat less and move more, these I think are odd comments):
1st one:
(Dietician) eat white bread instead of brown (me) isn't brown bread better for you? (Dietician) yes it is, but white bread has a couple of calories less (me) ??? is it ok if I stick to brown and cut back on something else (Dietician) yes, if you want to see someone else rather than me. (me) closed the door behind me
2nd one:
(Dietician) have you tried a slimming club? we only have a 4% success rate and they have about 12%success rate... (me) closed the door behind me
3rd one:
(Dietician)we dont usually see people like you unless you have health issues, (me) I am clinically obese as my bmi is 32, and I wanted to lose weight before I got as far as it causing health issues (Dietician) thats all very well and good, but we dont have time to do this for everyone (me) I am guessing most people dont make appts themselves, they are refferred after getting a health issue. (Dietician) that is how the system works, you get a refferal after an issue arises. (me) so, what can I do to prevent an issue arising and lose weight, (Dietician) here is a leaflet, bye. (me) closed the door behind me.
hopefully there will be people on here who can give you a more positive experience of an NHS dietician. maybe you will get a better experience if you go privately.
good luck, and my advice is to give sw a fair go for a few weeks and see how you get on.
x