Well I have now also tried the orange and nectarine one and it was also yummy. Maybe the mullers have too much water in them. I used WW ones which are 'thick and creamy'. I have also done some split ones, half toffee half vanilla.I tried it last week cos I bought one from tesco - and mine were yakky! kinda tasted like mushy ice crystals! I tried it with muller lights! sorry, dnot putting a dampner on it, just putting my two penneth in! xx