meadowbankles
Silver Member
How is it determined who wins this, please? I thought I had it in the bag 
But somebody else who lost less than me this week won ....
But somebody else who lost less than me this week won ....
Slimmer of thr Week
- Thread starter meadowbankles
- Start date
louis'mummy
Member
I'm sure that you cannot get it if it is your first week or if you haven't lost the week before...because these usually kick start bigger losses the week after x
meadowbankles
Silver Member
I see. I've lost weight every week, even if only half a pound. I lost 1.5 last week and got my half stone award. Tonight, the only person who lost more than me was a guy on a first week loss of 6lb. Image Therapy went right round the room and there were one or two 3lbs and a 3.5lb from the lady next to me. I lost 4lb so assumed I had won. But it was given to the lady next to me. I don't care about the basket of fruit, but I generally lose such small amounts that little things like that give me an incredible boost. Can the leader make a mistake? Or does that thingummy she carries tell her who has won?
gazter
needs to get a life
It sounds like maybe your consultant made a mistake (though it is suppose to be automated, ie the pda tells her). The rules are very simple. The person with the highest weight loss, as long as they didnt gain the previous week or it isnt first week in.
MelonCollie
Gold Member
I was told you can't get it if you stay the same, as well.
Talk to your consultant if you think you should have got it
Talk to your consultant if you think you should have got it
WannabeThinna
Full Member
In the last group I went to, if the SOTW hadn't stayed to group the consultant would give it to the most eligible person that had stayed. In my current group if the SOTW hasn't stayed the prize is raffled off.
Littlepink
Full Member
The pda works it out, it takes the losses from both weeks to work out who gets it xx
meadowbankles
Silver Member
I've spoken to the consultant today. She said it works it out over a two-week period and whoever has lost the most over two weeks is the winner - though the Slimming World website doesn't say that, it just says the biggest lost THAT WEEK as long as not on the back of a gain or a missed week or a first week loss.
Not that bothered, just needed to understand it.
Thanks for your replies everybody.
grollyzbird
Full Member
Oh this is interesting, I never knew that!
I am on my second week but have gained, I really must throw the bloody scales away!
I think I am giving myself a month to sort myself out, up my syns etc this week, I probably would have lost this week but a bad day on saturday meant I was stupid and ate a kebab!
I wish you lots of luck for slimmer of the week hun well done on your weight loss so far :clap:
xx
I am on my second week but have gained, I really must throw the bloody scales away!
I think I am giving myself a month to sort myself out, up my syns etc this week, I probably would have lost this week but a bad day on saturday meant I was stupid and ate a kebab!
I wish you lots of luck for slimmer of the week hun
well done on your weight loss so far :clap:xx
Littlepink
Full Member
I only know as im the one who does weigh in and writes up the awards
gazter
needs to get a life
That is not true. Unless there has been a change in policy.
meadowbankles
Silver Member
I didn't think it was right either. But she said the PDA told her the other lady had won, although she did agree with me that she had lost half a pound less than me this week.
janetelizabeth
Gold Member
I find it all a mystery....even when explained! Suffice to say, I never received that award!
Phoenix_Girl
Full Member
I had been told that it was a total of the week and the week before.
Whoever had the greatest value ended up with Slimmer of the Week.
I am not entirely sure if a gain excludes you but unless you had a phenomenal loss on the scales following a gain, you are unlikely to qualify.
The only reason I know this is because someone in my group lost 4 pounds on the week of weigh-in but the week before she had gained 4 pounds. That week I had lost 2 pounds but I had also lost another 3 the week before.
Said person who lost 4 pounds became extremely confrontational about the situation and was on the verge of demanding the basket for herself at which point I raised an eyebrow and gave the basket back to allow the consultant to give it to her as she was causing a scene.
Whoever had the greatest value ended up with Slimmer of the Week.
I am not entirely sure if a gain excludes you but unless you had a phenomenal loss on the scales following a gain, you are unlikely to qualify.
The only reason I know this is because someone in my group lost 4 pounds on the week of weigh-in but the week before she had gained 4 pounds. That week I had lost 2 pounds but I had also lost another 3 the week before.
Said person who lost 4 pounds became extremely confrontational about the situation and was on the verge of demanding the basket for herself at which point I raised an eyebrow and gave the basket back to allow the consultant to give it to her as she was causing a scene.
grollyzbird
Full Member
omg what an awful situation to be in!!
I feel so bad for you! thats terrible, even if she disagreed she could have had a quiet word with your consultant who could have explained rather than causing a scene and embarrassing everyone and herself!
xx
Phoenix_Girl
Full Member
I don't mind, the girl who was kicking up a fuss is not particularly mature anyway and has given some bum recipes to the group including tweaks which aren't endorsed by Slimming World.
Speaking of which, I haven't seen her or her mother for three weeks...
meadowbankles
Silver Member
good lord! I wasn't that bothered!!
However, we've got to the bottom of it. I DID win it but she thought I hadn't stayed to class and gave it to the "next" one. I KNEW she'd been calling me a different name that night. She gave me my certificate and sticker tonight. Sorry, I haven't been ignoring your replies, guys, I've been on holiday.
