Body Frame Ideal Weight vs BMI

Discussion in 'Cambridge Weight Plan' started by Xypher, 14 February 2010 Social URL.

  1. Xypher

    Xypher 2010 - Year I get slim :)

    Posts:
    160
    Likes Received:
    3
    Start Weight:
    19st5lb
    Current Weight:
    16st12lb
    Goal Weight:
    10st5lb
    Lost(%):
    2st7lb(12.92%)
    Diet:
    Cambridge Diet
    Hi All.. just got a quick question for ya :D Opinions appreciated...I was looking at this Body Frame Calculator which determines your ideal weight based on height and body frame size..

    Ideal Body Weight Calculator - MyDietExercise.com

    Now I set myself a target of hitting 145lbs which would give me a nice average 22.7 BMI (according to Calculate your BMI - Standard BMI Calculator)

    When I put in my target weight of 145 into the body frame calculator (i am medium frame apparantly) it tells me that this would leave me underweight.. not healthy weight :S And that I should be between 148 - 162.8 lbs (the high end of that range putting me in BMI 25+ so overweight according to BMI rules :S)

    So I was wondering what exactly should I be following here.. should I be following the BMI tables so stick with my 22.7 BMI.. or should I be following body frame size ideal weight range which would make me in the higher BMI range (23-26)

    What is more accurate way or determining what my ideal weight is? BMI or Body Frame? Thoughts on this topic appreciated

    Take Care xx
     
  2. Avatar

    MiniMins.com Matched Content

  3. Caz

    Caz Slimming down the aisle

    Posts:
    13,652
    Likes Received:
    95
    Start Weight:
    19st1.5lb
    Current Weight:
    18st6.8lb
    Goal Weight:
    13st0lb
    Lost(%):
    0st8.7lb(3.25%)
    Diet:
    Calorie Counting / SML / Orlistat
    I actually made a post about this calculator recently, and we were talking about how neither that nor BMI is perfect really. According to that calculator I should weigh between 160 and 178lbs which puts be just over a BMI of 25. But you can't really use BMI as the be all and end all, there are too many things it doesn't take into consideration such as frame, muscle etc. So personally I would set yourself the goal of the higher one, and then see how you feel when you get there and whether you think you could lose the extra or whether it feels right for your body. Is completely up to you really!
     
  4. boardwitless

    boardwitless Silver Member

    Posts:
    626
    Likes Received:
    23
    Start Weight:
    13st13lb
    Goal Weight:
    12st2lb
    I'm apparently underweight on all 3 frames - according to this I could be anything up to 14 stones which is not what I want to go back to, so it seems a bit high. I think you have to use your own judgement to a degree as age plays a part - there comes a time when you have to choose between your a*se and your face after a certain age, and also people carry weight differently, even BMI should only be used as a gauge rather than a definitive answer
     
  5. KD

    KD Gone fishing

    Posts:
    17,711
    Likes Received:
    757
    Diet:
    Was Cambridge, now maintaining
    Yeah. I agree. Don't worry too much. You'll probably know what's right for you when you get there. Besides, many doctors (including my own) take more notice of waist size for health rather than BMI. Apple shapes more at risk and all that.

    Having said that, the BMI heathy range (usually 20 to 25..depending where you look :D) is a very wide range. So personally, ignoring the apple vs pears shape thing, I would say a small frame would probably go nearer the BMI20 and the larger frame closer to the BMI25.

    Unless you are a body builder, or rugby player the healthy BMI range suits quite well.
     
Popular Forums
  1. MiniMins.com is a weight loss support community helping each other on their weight loss journey. We have a multitude of forums, from Slimming World and Exante, to Success Stories. Click the logo at the top right to return to the forum home page at any time.
Loading...